How Is Carbon Sequestration Calculated? Penghu's Biochar Coral Restoration Bricks — Understanding the Difference Between Taiwan's Voluntary Carbon Reduction and International Carbon Removal Certification
Contents(6)
  1. First, Let's Understand What a "Carbon Sink" Is — Not All "Carbon Reduction" Is the Same
  2. How Does Taiwan's Common Voluntary Carbon Reduction Differ from Internationally Certified Carbon Removal?
  3. How Was the Carbon Sink of This Restoration Brick Verified? The Complete Process of the Penghu Pilot Project
  4. Honest Thoughts on 0.625 Tonnes of Carbon Sink: The Volume Isn't High, but the Editor Thinks This Path Is Worth Taking
  5. Next Steps: Connecting Carbon Sinks to Sustainable Tourism and Biodiversity Credits
  6. Conclusion: The Carbon Sink Is Just the Starting Point — What the Editor Is Testing Is a Whole New Set of Possibilities

After the previous article on Penghu's biochar coral restoration bricks was published, the most common question the Editor received wasn't about how well the coral was growing — it was: "How exactly was that carbon sink calculated?" This article sets out to answer that clearly. The batch of restoration bricks deployed at Hang Bay, Penghu by Shin Kong Life Charity Foundation, Taiwan Shin Kong Security, Guangtai Huaneng, and BlueTrend has received the world's first international carbon removal certification for a coral restoration project, with a carbon sink of 0.625 tonnes of CO₂ equivalent. Here's the key point: that number isn't large, but the verification process it went through is very different from the voluntary carbon reduction mechanisms most people in Taiwan are familiar with. The Editor will use this pilot project to help you understand what a carbon sink is, how Taiwan's voluntary emission reductions differ from international carbon removal certification, and why the Editor believes this path is worth continuing to explore.

First, Let's Understand What a "Carbon Sink" Is — Not All "Carbon Reduction" Is the Same

A Carbon Sink Is the Earth's "Carbon Warehouse"

The term "carbon sink" has been coming up a lot lately, but it's easy to get confused about what it actually means. The Editor will explain it in the plainest possible terms: a carbon sink is a "carbon warehouse" that absorbs CO₂ from the atmosphere and locks it away. Forests, oceans, and soil are all natural carbon sinks. When plants use photosynthesis to absorb carbon into their bodies, that's the most classic example of carbon storage in action.

The problem is, having a warehouse isn't enough — you also need to prove that "the carbon really went in and won't quietly leak back out" before that carbon account is considered valid. This is the most critical part of the whole story, and you'll feel it more concretely when we get to the verification process.

Emission Reduction and Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) Are Not the Same Thing

There's a concept that many people mix up, and the Editor wants to help you distinguish between them first. Carbon reduction actually takes two quite different approaches.

The first is called "emission reduction" — that is, reducing or avoiding emissions. When you replace old machinery with energy-efficient equipment or switch to solar power generation, the carbon that would have been emitted simply isn't. That's reducing output. The second is called "carbon removal," or Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) — this means physically capturing CO₂ that is already floating in the atmosphere and storing it long-term. The former is "producing less waste," while the latter is "picking up the trash that's already been thrown out." They are completely different things. Biochar has been listed by the UN's IPCC as one of the CDR technologies with significant potential, because it can take carbon that plants have absorbed and lock it into a stable solid for hundreds of years.

台灣潛點地圖掛布2027 汶萊六天五夜潛水與文化之旅2027 媽媽島長尾鯊潛旅2027 斯米蘭 Raga 船宿聖誕跨年團

How Does Taiwan's Common Voluntary Carbon Reduction Differ from Internationally Certified Carbon Removal?

Now that you understand the difference between emission reduction and carbon removal, this section gets to the core of the article. The "carbon credits" and "voluntary reductions" that people in Taiwan most commonly hear about are actually quite different from the "international carbon removal certification" that the Penghu bricks received.

Taiwan's Voluntary Emission Reductions: Mostly "Reducing Emissions," Registered Domestically

Taiwan currently operates on a carbon fee-first approach, supplemented by the Ministry of Environment's "Voluntary Emission Reduction Projects." Simply put, a company submits its own carbon reduction project — for example, switching to energy-efficient equipment, afforestation, or installing renewable energy — to the Ministry of Environment for review. Once approved, the company receives "emission reduction credits," commonly known as carbon credits, which can be registered domestically and traded on the Taiwan Carbon Solution Exchange.

This mechanism is important, but have you noticed? Most of the emission reduction credits issued in Taiwan are of the "emission-reduction" type. Domestic methodologies for natural carbon sinks are still in their early stages. And because it operates under domestic rules, it primarily corresponds to domestic carbon fee offsets and ESG disclosure — international buyers don't necessarily recognize it.

Biochar Carbon Sinks: Internationally Direct-Certified "Permanent Carbon Removal"

The Penghu bricks took a different route. The biochar used passed EBC — the European Biochar Certificate — managed by Carbon Standards International (CSI) in Switzerland. Guangtai Huaneng is the first and currently the only biochar manufacturer in Taiwan to have obtained EBC certification.

After passing EBC, this batch of biochar had its net carbon removal calculated according to the Global Biochar C-Sink international standard and was registered in the Global C-Sink Registry. In other words, this is a "permanent carbon removal" credit recognized by the international voluntary carbon market — not a domestic version. How seriously does the international community take biochar? According to statistics from CDR.fyi, approximately 87% of removal-type carbon credits in the voluntary carbon market currently come from biochar, which shows just how highly regarded it is in the field of carbon removal.

新光人壽慈善基金會團隊在澎湖海域啟動珊瑚復育計畫

Shin Kong Life Charity Foundation, together with Taiwan Shin Kong Security, Guangtai Huaneng, and BlueTrend, launched a Coral Restoration Programme in the waters of Penghu, completing the world's first natural carbon sink initiative stretching from land to ocean.

One Line to Tell Them Apart: Voluntary Reduction vs. Carbon Removal

If you only want to remember one sentence, the Editor will boil it down for you: Taiwan's common voluntary emission reductions are mostly "reducing emissions, registered domestically." The international carbon removal certification that the Penghu bricks obtained means "capturing carbon back, registering internationally, and storing it permanently." One proves you produced less carbon; the other proves you actually put carbon into storage. Their credibility and international recognition are on entirely different levels. This is also why, despite the modest carbon sink volume, the Editor considers this pilot project highly meaningful.

How Was the Carbon Sink of This Restoration Brick Verified? The Complete Process of the Penghu Pilot Project

After all this talk about standards, you're probably wondering: in practice, how was that 0.625 tonnes of carbon sink verified step by step? The Editor breaks down the full process for you.

Starting with EBC-Certified Biochar

The first step takes place on land. Biomass feedstocks — such as wood, bamboo, and agricultural or forestry residues — are pyrolyzed in a high-temperature, oxygen-limited environment to produce stable biochar. This biochar must first pass EBC certification, confirming that its production process and carbon content both meet the required standards. The biochar is then mixed into low-carbon cement to form the coral restoration bricks. The team also repeatedly adjusted the particle size, addition ratio, and formula of the biochar to ensure the bricks can withstand the high salinity, high corrosivity, and long-term water currents of the marine environment.

澎湖杭灣生物炭珊瑚復育磚的施作流程

From preparing materials on land, securing the biochar restoration bricks, to transplanting coral — every step is documented, forming the foundation upon which the carbon sink can be verified.

dMRV Digital Monitoring: Making Every Data Point Traceable

Once the bricks are deployed underwater, the main event is monitoring. This project introduced dMRV — digital Measurement, Reporting, and Verification. It automates and near-real-times the collection and upload of underwater monitoring data as much as possible, with the goal of making every data point transparent and traceable, so that anyone who wants to check can do so — rather than simply taking the team's word for it.

The Editor considers dMRV a critical link in this process. The biggest risk in carbon accounting is "self-reporting." Only by putting data in full public view and subjecting it to third-party standard scrutiny can a carbon account truly stand up to scrutiny.

透過數位 dMRV 系統讓每一筆數據透明可追溯

Through the digital dMRV system, every contribution is made transparent and traceable. Every data point is a genuine commitment to the planet.

Calculating 0.625 Tonnes and Registering in the Global C-Sink Registry

In the final step, the net carbon stored by this batch of bricks was calculated according to the Global Biochar C-Sink methodology. After the bricks deployed in 2025 completed the full verification process, the carbon sink was officially issued and registered in the Global C-Sink Registry on 21 April 2026, amounting to 0.625 tonnes of CO₂ equivalent (Registry record Stock ID 27540). From a handful of charcoal on land, to a brick on the seafloor, to a carbon sink record in a registry system — the entire chain has been completed. As an aside, these bricks have been tested against real ocean conditions and their structure remains intact, confirming that the biochar composite material can truly withstand the marine environment.

Global C-Sink Registry 全球碳匯註冊系統的生物炭碳匯紀錄

Global C-Sink makes every data point trackable. The sequestration volume and duration of this batch of biochar carbon sinks are registered in the global registry system, accessible to anyone.

Honest Thoughts on 0.625 Tonnes of Carbon Sink: The Volume Isn't High, but the Editor Thinks This Path Is Worth Taking

The Editor wants to be straightforward here: 0.625 tonnes of carbon sink isn't actually very much. To put it in perspective, it's roughly equivalent to what a small petrol car emits driving about 3,000 km — a little over two laps around the main island of Taiwan. At this stage, it's not yet possible to generate significant revenue or sustain a business purely from the carbon sink value of these bricks.

生物炭珊瑚復育磚透過生物炭技術將碳元素永久封存

Every restoration brick carries the responsibility of carbon reduction, using biochar technology to permanently lock away carbon.

So where does the value of this pilot project lie? The Editor believes it lies in "proving the methodology works." This is the world's first coral restoration case that moves from land to ocean and obtains international carbon removal certification. It shows us that biochar doesn't only have to be buried in soil — it can go into the sea and become a home for coral, while also taking the entire measurable, reportable, and verifiable process through a real-world marine setting for the first time. A pilot project is never about chasing volume; it's about verifying whether the path is viable. First, explore the route — then there's a chance to scale up gradually in the future. The Editor believes that being willing to honestly acknowledge "the volume isn't high" while still diligently completing each verification step is itself something worth doing.

Next Steps: Connecting Carbon Sinks to Sustainable Tourism and Biodiversity Credits

If carbon sink volumes can't scale up quickly in the short term, where does this project go from here? The Editor believes the key isn't to scale carbon sinks in isolation, but to connect them to two other tracks — that's where the value compounds.

Sustainable Tourism: Dive One Tank, Spend a Day as a Citizen Scientist

The first track is sustainable tourism. Starting in 2026, with support from Shin Kong Life Charity Foundation, BlueTrend and local dive shops are transforming the Hang Bay restoration area into a live venue for "sustainable resilience tourism." People who come to dive don't need to be scientists — they just need to be able to dive and take photos. Following the dive guide, they can help record coral growth patterns and turn underwater observations into real scientific data. The Editor's team has also designed a coral growth pattern identification card, making reporting feel as approachable as completing a game mission.

珊瑚生長型態功能群公民科學家回報任務辨識卡

The coral growth pattern identification cards designed by the Editor's team allow divers to identify and report what they observe underwater by following the cards, turning every dive into a citizen scientist mission.

Biodiversity Credits: The Next Piece of the Puzzle the Editor Is Exploring

The second track is "biodiversity credits" — something the Editor's team is actively working toward while still in the exploration phase. To be clear upfront: this mechanism is still at the stage of establishing international rules, and the Editor's team is still researching how to connect to it. No one can issue them directly right now, and this article is not announcing that we can sell them.

But the direction is clear. When the coral diversity and returning fish populations recorded by divers can be converted one by one into verifiable data, there will be a future opportunity to link them into a biodiversity credit mechanism. Carbon sinks address "carbon"; biodiversity credits address "the diversity of life" — the two happen to fill in each other's blind spots. By tying carbon sinks, sustainable tourism, and biodiversity credits together into one package, companies will have a long-term reason to direct ESG resources into the effort, and coral restoration won't be a one-off exercise that runs out of funding.

新光人壽慈善基金會讓潛水旅遊與環境韌性結合

Shin Kong Life Charity Foundation has been investing in coral restoration at Hang Bay, Penghu since 2025. In 2026, it is calling on divers to join in growth pattern monitoring, in response to the United Nations' "2027 International Year of Sustainable and Resilient Tourism."

Conclusion: The Carbon Sink Is Just the Starting Point — What the Editor Is Testing Is a Whole New Set of Possibilities

Returning to the opening question: how exactly is a carbon sink calculated? The answer is that it requires a complete set of international standards, third-party certification, and dMRV digital monitoring to verify, step by step, the fact of carbon sequestration — and this is precisely the greatest difference between Taiwan's voluntary carbon reduction and international carbon removal certification.

The carbon sink volume of the Penghu pilot project is not high, and the Editor won't exaggerate its results. But what it is genuinely doing is bringing biochar from land into the ocean, walking a verifiable carbon removal process through a real marine environment, and then trying to connect it to sustainable tourism and the still-developing biodiversity credit mechanism. This path has only just begun. Whether the volume will scale up and whether the mechanism can take shape are things the Editor is still continuously observing. But being willing to try honestly, and doing the verification rigorously — that in itself is something worth doing.

Further Reading

Related Links

References

  1. EBC (2012–2025), European Biochar Certificate – Guidelines for a Sustainable Production of Biochar, Carbon Standards International (CSI), Switzerland, Version 10.5E, 14 August 2025.
  2. Global Biochar C-Sink Standard & Global C-Sink Registry Documentation.
  3. IPCC, Climate Change 2022: Mitigation of Climate Change, Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) Pathways.
  4. Economic Daily News, "Shin Kong Life Charity Foundation Advances Ocean Conservation — World's First Biochar Coral Restoration Bricks Deployed in Penghu," 5 June 2026, money.udn.com.
  5. K. Chowdhury, S. Basu, M. Pramanik & T. Pleninger, "Blue infrastructure as nature-based solutions for urban sustainability: Evaluating local perceptions from four Indian megacities", Nature-Based Solutions, Volume 7, June 2025, sciencedirect.com. Explores the role of blue infrastructure in ecological restoration, climate resilience, and sustainable development, providing a theoretical basis for the integrated application of marine restoration and natural carbon removal.

(This article is adapted from a press release by Guangtai Huaneng, with supplementary popular-science explanation on carbon sinks and carbon removal certification provided by BlueTrend.)

海編"布魯陳"

海編"布魯陳"

我是布魯陳,平常喜歡帶著大相機下海找生物,如果你有海洋議題歡迎找我聊聊,約我吃飯更歡迎!