Taiwan's Precious Coral Fishery: An Industry at the Crossroads of Cultural Heritage and Ecological Crisis
Contents(7)
  1. Coral's Place in Human Civilization: From Ancient Texts to Qing Dynasty Court Beads
  2. The Development and Peak of Taiwan's Precious Coral Fishery
  3. The Cost of Unchecked Harvesting: The Ecological Damage of the Coral Fishery to Taiwan's Waters
  4. From Laissez-Faire to Regulation: The Fisheries Agency Steps In
  5. Toward an Orderly Phase-Out: Calling for Consumer Change and Support for Fisher Transition
  6. Conclusion
  7. References

The waters off Taiwan's Northeast Coast and Penghu were once among the world's most important sources of precious coral. The red and pink coral harvested from these seas once supported an entire supply chain stretching from harvesting and processing to export. The status of precious coral in Eastern civilization was not a modern development: from the medicinal uses recorded in the Bencao Gangmu (Compendium of Materia Medica) to the rank-denoting court beads of the Qing dynasty, coral had long been regarded as a rare material of high commercial value. This cultural legacy is part of the historical backdrop that once motivated the deployment of large numbers of vessels and workers into Taiwan's coral fishery. Yet precious coral grows only a few millimetres per year; a colony mature enough to be carved into jewellery may take decades or even centuries to develop. The damage inflicted on seafloor habitats and surrounding biological communities by traditional trawling and grappling operations is far more severe than harvest records alone suggest. This article examines how Taiwan's precious coral fishery traveled from the peak of its productive power to today's situation — one of declining vessel numbers under the oversight of the Fisheries Agency of the Ministry of Agriculture — and asks where this industry should go from here, and how consumer choices can shape that answer.

Coral's Place in Human Civilization: From Ancient Texts to Qing Dynasty Court Beads

The perception of coral as a rare and precious material is not a modern phenomenon. The Bencao Gangmu, compiled by Li Shizhen of the Ming dynasty, listed coral in the section on metals and stones, continuing a tradition dating back to the Xinxiu Bencao of the Tang dynasty, which had already catalogued coral and other marine organisms as medicinal materials ground and taken as medicine. These records show that coral occupied a dual role in Eastern civilization from the very beginning — both medicinal and symbolic — and that coral trade had generated demand along China's coastline for a very long time.

That demand reached its peak during the Qing dynasty. Qing officials wore court bead necklaces (chaozhu) of different materials according to their rank; second-rank officials wore coral beads, a status second only to the ruby beads worn by first-rank officials, marking them as senior officials or those attending the most important ceremonial occasions. The National Palace Museum holds numerous pieces of coral court beads and carved objects, their rich red luster a concrete testament to the intersection of Qing imperial craftsmanship and hierarchical ritual.

Qing dynasty officials' court beads were crafted from coral and other gemstones. Officials of the second rank and above wore coral court beads as a mark of status, and this demand for coral fueled centuries of harvesting along Asia's coastlines. Portrait of the Kangxi Emperor in Court Dress, collection of the National Palace Museum.

Qing dynasty officials' court beads were crafted from coral and other gemstones. Officials of the second rank and above wore coral court beads as a mark of status, and this demand for coral fueled centuries of harvesting along Asia's coastlines. Portrait of the Kangxi Emperor in Court Dress, collection of the National Palace Museum.

From the medicinal entries of the Bencao Gangmu to the rank-marking court beads of the Qing dynasty, coral's place in Eastern civilization has always revolved around two qualities: rarity and an irreplaceable beauty. These are precisely the qualities that made the coral industry commercially viable. Taiwan's precious coral fishery emerged, in a sense, as the inheritor of a civilizational lineage stretching back hundreds of years.

台灣潛點地圖掛布2027 汶萊六天五夜潛水與文化之旅2027 媽媽島長尾鯊潛旅2027 斯米蘭 Raga 船宿聖誕跨年團

The Development and Peak of Taiwan's Precious Coral Fishery

Taiwan's precious coral fishery inherited the longstanding demand for coral along China's coast and took shape in the right geographic and oceanic conditions. In November 1923, a Japanese fisherman named Yamamoto Akitarō accidentally hauled up a branch of red coral on a longline northwest of Pengjiayu. Government and private interests soon began planning development, and that same year the Tōyō Coral Company and the Taiwan Fisheries Corporation coral market were established, formally inaugurating Taiwan's coral fishery. The earliest fishing grounds were concentrated in northern and northeastern Taiwan's waters; Penghu's coral deposits were not discovered until 1934. These fishing grounds lay at depths of several hundred metres. Early harvesting relied on rudimentary trawl nets and hand-cranked winches — a risky operation — but the high unit price of coral made the risk worth taking for fishers.

Taiwan's coral fishery reached its production peak in the 1960s and 1970s, with the height of the industry occurring around the 1970s, when Taiwan accounted for approximately 80% of the precious coral sold on the global market, earning the country the nickname "Kingdom of Coral." In the era when coral commanded its highest prices, a single coral vessel bringing in a haul of premium red or pink coral could sustain an entire family's livelihood — which is why, despite the demanding working conditions, fishers continued to enter the trade.

Trawl vessels crowd the harbor at Nanfang'ao. The red roof of Jinan Temple is visible in the distance. This harbor was once the most important distribution hub of Taiwan's coral industry. (Photo: Jimmy Liao / Pexels)

Trawl vessels crowd the harbor at Nanfang'ao. The red roof of Jinan Temple is visible in the distance. This harbor was once the most important distribution hub of Taiwan's coral industry. (Photo: Jimmy Liao / Pexels)

From the time of its construction during the Japanese colonial era, Nanfang'ao served as the central hub for the collection, distribution, processing, and trading of precious coral — and was known as the "Homeland of Coral" during the Kingdom of Coral's most glorious years. In the 1970s and 1980s, when Taiwan led the world in precious coral production, Nanfang'ao was the operational core of the entire supply chain: vessel provisioning, ore grading, carving and processing, and wholesale trading were all largely carried out here. Inside Jinan Temple, Nanfang'ao's most prominent landmark, stands a Mazu statue carved from deep-sea precious coral and gold — the world's first Mazu image crafted from coral. This statue's existence made coral not merely the lifeblood of Nanfang'ao's economy, but an integral part of its local faith and community identity.

The existence of this Mazu statue made coral not merely the lifeblood of Nanfang'ao's economy, but an integral part of its local faith and community identity.

The existence of this Mazu statue made coral not merely the lifeblood of Nanfang'ao's economy, but an integral part of its local faith and community identity.

The economic benefits of the coral fishery shaped, to a significant degree, the industrial structure of fishing villages along the Northeast Coast. It was not until the industry faced the twin pressures of resource depletion and a younger generation unwilling to carry on the trade that it was gradually forced to a crossroads of transformation.

The Cost of Unchecked Harvesting: The Ecological Damage of the Coral Fishery to Taiwan's Waters

A large part of what makes precious coral so valuable is precisely how extraordinarily slowly it grows. According to Professor Dai Chang-feng of National Taiwan University's Institute of Oceanography, the basal diameter of red coral increases by only about 0.5 mm per year, and the central axis grows at a rate of less than 7 mm per year. This growth rate is far slower than the pace of harvesting. Unlike common fishery resources such as fish or shellfish, which can replenish their populations within a relatively short time, coral that is severed or uprooted represents an almost permanent loss to the seafloor habitat. No new coral reef bed will replace it in the short term.

A healthy coral reef provides the three-dimensional structure that fish and benthic organisms depend on for habitat. Once destroyed by trawling, even partial recovery can take decades. (Photo: Tom Fisk / Pexels)

A healthy coral reef provides the three-dimensional structure that fish and benthic organisms depend on for habitat. Once destroyed by trawling, even partial recovery can take decades. (Photo: Tom Fisk / Pexels)

The damage inflicted on the seabed by early coral harvesting operations was comprehensive. Not only the target coral was taken: other benthic organisms sharing the same area, soft coral communities, and even the reef structures that fish depend on for habitat could all be destroyed or swept up in the fishing gear in the process — a phenomenon known in fisheries management as bycatch. The harm to these non-target species rarely entered the industry's profit-and-loss calculations, yet it represents the real ecological cost occurring on the ocean floor.

From the perspective of conservation biology, coral is fundamentally more analogous to an old-growth tree in a forest than to a renewable fishery resource. The logic underpinning fish and crustacean harvesting rests on the premise that "population replenishment is faster than the rate of removal." That premise simply does not hold for coral, which grows so slowly. Once harvesting pressure exceeds the rate at which coral grows naturally and reef beds can rebuild, the seafloor habitat moves along a one-way trajectory of degradation rather than achieving the kind of dynamic equilibrium that conventional fisheries management typically aims for.

The branching arms of red coral require a century to grow to maturity on the seafloor — a rate of growth far outpaced by human harvesting. (Photo: The New York Public Library / Unsplash)

The branching arms of red coral require a century to grow to maturity on the seafloor — a rate of growth far outpaced by human harvesting. (Photo: The New York Public Library / Unsplash)

This is why the precious coral industry has always differed fundamentally in its underlying logic from other marine fisheries. The problem is not whether individual fishers operate with care; it is that the resource the industry depends upon is inherently unsuited to being managed and exploited as a fishery in the first place.

From Laissez-Faire to Regulation: The Fisheries Agency Steps In

The longstanding problem of the precious coral industry was never that coral lacked value, but rather that in the early years there was no management system aligned with ecological reality. The Fisheries Agency of the Ministry of Agriculture subsequently established dedicated management regulations for coral harvesting operations, formally bringing what had previously been a grey area into the regulatory framework, and guiding the industry on the principle of maintaining — rather than expanding — its existing operational scale.

Coral fishing is classified as a sideline activity for licensed fishing vessels. Only the harvesting of precious coral is permitted, and new vessel applications have not been accepted for many years; only operators already registered with harvesting equipment at an early date are recognised. According to information held by the Fisheries Agency, the number of registered coral fishing vessels was far greater in earlier years than it is today, and has decreased markedly since the regulated management system came into effect.

In recent years the Fisheries Agency has continued to review the relevant regulations, adjusting the framework in the direction of encouraging the replacement of aging vessels and allowing the total number of vessels to gradually decrease, while also reviewing the criteria for operational qualifications so that regulations better reflect actual operating conditions.

These directions of reform reveal that the Fisheries Agency does not intend to immediately terminate the industry, but rather seeks an incremental balance between fishers' livelihoods and resource sustainability. This is key to understanding the current state of Taiwan's precious coral fishery: it is no longer an industry left to harvest without constraint, but a regulated fishery on a path toward an orderly phase-out.

Toward an Orderly Phase-Out: Calling for Consumer Change and Support for Fisher Transition

The precious coral fishery has arrived at this point not because of fishers' greed or disregard for the law, but because the industry's commercial logic has been in fundamental conflict with coral's growth rate from the very beginning. According to data published by the Ministry of Agriculture, Taiwan's registered precious coral fishing fleet originally numbered 96 vessels; in recent years that figure has been declining annually toward 60, a reduction achieved through the Fisheries Agency's progressively tightening management measures rather than through natural market contraction. If society believes precious coral should no longer be harvested, the most direct and effective course of action is to return to the demand side: stop buying coral jewellery and decorative objects. As demand falls, harvesting naturally decreases — a mechanism closer to the real logic of an industry phase-out than an outright ban.

This does not mean immediately stripping currently active fishers of their livelihoods. Under the "Regulations Governing the Issuance of Fishing Vessel Construction Permits and Fishery Licenses," new fishery licenses for coral fishing are in principle no longer issued; only existing licenses may be renewed upon expiry, and the fleet shrinks naturally as original license holders change occupations or vessels are lost and not replaced. Research data from National Taiwan Ocean University also indicates that following the implementation of new management measures in 2009, the fishery has stabilised at 60 registered vessels, with approximately 3 actively harvesting per year; the 2014 amendment to the management measures further introduced an annual total allowable catch of 6 metric tonnes, with a public announcement issued by the central competent authority when catches reach 5.4 metric tonnes, after which operations must cease within 7 days of the announcement. This is a textbook example of an industry phase-out: respecting the livelihoods and skills that fishers have accumulated over many years, while allowing the industry's overall scale to gradually contract. But as long as demand persists, fishers have no incentive to transition to other work, and the current system will merely perpetuate the industry's scale rather than genuinely reducing it. Social consensus and consumer choices are the critical driving force.

Beyond consumer self-restraint, government and industry stakeholders must also squarely address the career transition needs of currently active coral fishers — providing vocational training and transition support so that these families have the opportunity to move into more sustainable development-oriented fisheries or ocean-related work, while simultaneously phasing out the cultivation of new entrants into an industry destined to shrink.

This is not about portraying the coral fishery as something that deserves punishment. It is about acknowledging that when an industry is fundamentally incompatible with the ecological carrying capacity it depends on, society has a responsibility to help it exit with dignity — rather than leaving both fishers and the ocean to pay the price as resources run dry.

Conclusion

The question posed by the precious coral fishery has never been whether to ban it overnight, but rather whether this industry — so deeply dependent on a scarce, slow-growing resource — can ultimately coexist with the ocean's pace of ecological recovery. The Fisheries Agency's approach of gradually contracting the fleet through vessel replacement is a pragmatic, incremental path. But consumer choices matter equally: as market demand for coral jewellery and decorative pieces declines, the industry's exit will come more naturally and with less conflict. What we hope to see is an endpoint that is relatively humane for both active fishers and marine ecosystems — not a simple prohibition that entrenches opposition.

References

Cover image: Pink Coral. National Palace Museum, Taipei, CC BY 4.0 @ www.npm.gov.tw

海編"布魯陳"

海編"布魯陳"

我是布魯陳,平常喜歡帶著大相機下海找生物,如果你有海洋議題歡迎找我聊聊,約我吃飯更歡迎!